"Because he attempted to kill me first." (only if you uncovered Gisette's plot in week 2) +1
All Other Answers - Instant Fail
+1
All others Instant fail
"And why would I care about that?"
Because you have fallen in love with me. Instant Fail
"I'm not sure..." +0
"I don't think it mattered who..." +0
"I don't know you..."
Instant Fail
+0
+0
+0
"But amuse me. Guess."
"I think perhaps you were trying..." +
"I think you believe the Isle..."+6.5
"I think you were trying to get justice..." +0
"I think you were amused..." +1.5
+
+6.5
+0
+1.5
"So tell me, how did I do it?" - Needs more testing. I can get him confessing without picking a theory.
You killed + He attempted to kill me + I don't know you/I think you believe the isle = skip picking theories/confession (can confirm this)
You killed + He attempted to kill me + I don't know you/I think you were amused +3 correct theories = confession
You killed + He attempted to kill me + any other non-instant fail "why would I care" answer + 4 correct theories = confession.
If the "I think you believe the Isle..." option is chosen then you can add all non-instant fail wrong theories without failing.
If the "I think you were amused..." option is chosen you can add 1 wrong theory if you pick all 4 correct theories.
Not choosing either option requires all 4 correct theories + no wrong theories. I've added point values that hopefully reflect that.)Some answers seem to have more "value/points" than others.)
"You drowned him" Instant Fail
"You used a rose thorn" +0.5
"You strangled him with a rope" Instant Fail
"A horse is missing. You are the cause" +0.5
"You wrote a note and framed Gisette for it"+0.5
"You hid his body..." -1.5
Fail
+0.5
Fail
+0.5
-1.5
"You made sure his sister left..." -1.5
"You paid someone else..." -1.5
"You arranged an accident. Here."+0.5
(That's all the theories you have) +0
-1.5
-1.5
+0.5
+0
"One question then. One truth."
"I know somehow the murders are connected..." (Then search staff quarters to find the murder weapon)
while knowing the true cause of death
The Other Murder - Kade Theory Picking
Kade killed the servant
Because he attempted to kill the MC first
Anything other than in love with the MC
Choose rose thorn, missing horse, framing Gisette, staging an accident, (you can also say he made the sister leave and hid the body but I don’t know how that affects things) and then
Say those are the only theories you have
-> Don't choose "drowned" or "rope". He will end the discussion with: "You have disappointed me"
->Don't choose "paid somebody" with most other combinations of theories.
The MC doesn't need to pick one of the theories to make him confess. Just pick "Those are the only theories you have". The MCs need to know certain things/secrets and need to be able to connect right.
